Rich, yet still soft and decadent, these thumbprint caramel shortbread cookies will be all the rage during your annual cookie exchange (or be like me and not share any at all!)
I am so happy to be a part of a Canadian cookie exchange this year. No cookies are physically being exchanged, but it did bring together Canadian food bloggers with their latest and greatest creations.
While I am all over these thumbprint caramel shortbread cookies (and swear they are the best!), other bloggers went through a lot of work, and it would be great if you could check out their recipes at the end of this post 🙂
If I had to pick one Christmas cookie to enjoy each year, it would be a real hard toss up between snickerdoodles and shortbread cookies. My caramilk stuffed snickerdoodles were all the rage last year, and I needed something to top it. Since I LOVE caramel sauce (check out my dry method caramel sauce,) I knew I had to incorportate that somehow. And that is how these thumbprint caramel shortbread cookies were born!
Originally I had planned to make some sort of royal icing decorated cookie but I completely ran out of time. With the fine attention to detail and having to wait for the royal icing to dry between each layer, I knew there was no way it was happening. So I opted to go with these caramel shortbread cookies instead and I was soooooo happy!
Then again, I did hit some hiccups along the way but that is why I am here: to share with you the right way to make cookies so you don’t have to deal with the pain I did.
First off, if using homemade caramel sauce, be sure to make it a day in advance and allow it to firm up in the fridge. My first batch of cookies was great, except I was too impatient in allowing my caramel sauce to cool so it just ran everywhere. My fault.
Second: Don’t go too crazy with the caramel sauce. The whole idea is a “thumbprint.” I am all about the caramel sauce, but if you add too much they are just going to run off the sides. Plus, the shortbread is fantastic on its own, so you don’t want to mask any flavours 🙂
Third: To chill the dough before baking or not. Very rarely do I refrigerate my cookie dough rounds before baking. I know some people swear by it, but I dont’ care for it. I went both ways with this recipe, testing out how they turned out chilled from the refrigerator, and baked just straight from the mixer.
To be honest, I prefered the ones baked straight from the bowl, no chilling required. If you look at my pictures, the cookies with the feathery looking edges were the chilled ones, and the soft edges were the non-chilled ones. Personal preferece, but just letting you know 🙂
And there we have it! These thumbprint caramel shortbread cookies are a adaptation from my shortbread cookies (which were originally by Uncle Bill from Food.com) The recipe is fool-proof and is probably my most requested cookie recipe every year!
Yields 2 1/2 dozen
15 minPrep Time
11 minCook Time
26 minTotal Time
- 1 cup salted butter, room temperature
- 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/4 cup granulated sugar
- 1/4 cup confectioners' sugar
- 1/4 tsp. almond extract
- Store-bought or homemade caramel sauce
- Combine butter and sugars into the bowl of your stand mixer. Beat until light and fluffy, about 5 minutes. Mix in almond extract. Pour in flour and mix until JUST combined.
- Preheat oven to 350F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or silicone liner. Measure out one tablespoon-sized portions and roll into a ball. Use your finger or thumb to make a "thumbprint" in the cookie.
- Bake for 11-13 minutes. Allow to cool 5 minutes on baking sheet before moving to wire rack.
- Place a SMALL amount of caramel sauce into each thumbprint, and move cookies to fridge so caramel firms up. If you find your caramel is too runny (I store my homemade batch in the fridge so it is nice and firm to work with) then mix in some confectioners' sugar until you have a caramel paste.
If your caramel sauce is loose, mix in some confectioners' sugar so that your caramel thumbprint stays in place and doesn't melt.
As I said, it wasn’t just me putting in the effort to come up with a delicious Christmas cookie recipe, but many Canadian food bloggers as well. I finally had the chance to meet many of them in person this past October and cannot wait to see them again (but this cookie exchange will have to do for now!)
Welcome to this very special Canadian Cookie Collaboration between the Canadian Food Creatives and the Canadian Christmas Cookie Exchange. #CDNFoodCreatives
Visit these Canadian Bloggers to save all of these sweet holiday cookie recipes:
- Austrian Husarenkrapferl Cookies by Evelyne at CulturEatz
- Candy Cane Kissed Chocolate Chip Cookies by Fareen at Food Mamma
- Chocolate Candy Cane Biscotti by Amanda at Peppers & Pennies
- Christmas Piñata Cookies by Karin at The Kitchen Divas
- Coconut shortbread Sandwiches by Taylor at The Girl on Bloor
- Crispy Spicy Almond Roccoco Italian Cookie Recipe by Maria at She Loves Biscotti
- Double Chocolate Mint Cookies by Diana at 365 Days of Easy Recipes
- Eggnog Madeleines by Samantha at My Kitchen Love
- Eisenbahner (Railroad) Cookies by Vicky at Tiny Sweet Tooth
- Gluten Free Thumprint cookies by Jenn at One Heart One Family
- Jewish Shortbread Cookie Pie by Jo-Anna at A Pretty Life in the Suburbs
- Nanny’s Molasses Cookies by Laura at Bluenose Baker
- Peppermint Macarons by Cristina at I Say Nomato
- Sablés Bretons with Chocolate Caramel Beurre Salé by Hilary at Cocoa Bean, the Vegetable
- Stained Glass Gingerbread Cookies by Megan at Food & Whine
- Stuffed Double Chocolate Turtle Cookies by Cassie at Crumb Kitchen
- Thumbprint Caramel Shortbread Cookies by Kacey at The Cookie Writer
- Toasted Flour Sablés by Kimberlie at The Finer Cookie
- Triple Chocolate Pistachio Cookies by Marie at Food Nouveau
- Whole Wheat Dark Chocolate Ginger Crisps by Melanie at The Refreshanista
Sharing is caring! Please post on social media if you like with the hashtag #CDNFoodCreatives!